• 3 Posts
  • 27 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 19th, 2024

help-circle

  • ve seen too much of it shit all over people who lack education, context, or ability to understand,

    It kinda irks me seeing comrades engage with people assuming they’re arguing in good faith and immediately it turns out it’s just unabashed western chauvinism. The fact that you refer to Debord is just the icing on the cake.

    I’ve read Debord, guy had a good fifteen page essay hidden inside The Society of the Spectacle and then over a hundred pages of masturbatory inscrutability of the kind Zizek perfected and good old french chauvinism. I put more stock in the works credited by people who actually achieved revolution and then a better quality of life for their nations through them. A social science requires falsifiability.

    On the other hand, there is Lenin boiling down in a hundred pages a very thorough understanding of Marxist thought and the critical steps the revolution must take to defend itself as well as the reasons for it. No fluff, no academicist posturing, just keeping in the Marxist tradition of making the subject only as complex as it needs to be. Then he went and fucking proved it with his practice.

    Capital isn’t an entry level text, it is a thorough study of the mechanisms of capital, the value form, the objects of financial speculation and their interaction with the real material economy. Critique of the Gotha Programme, The Poverty of Philosophy, The German Ideology, even Socialism: Utopic and Scientific by Engels are thorough, clear, and concise. And they work.



  • Grapho@lemmy.mltoMemes@lemmy.mlHappy Jan 6 to all who celebrate
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    2 days ago

    What you’re saying is exactly the discourse COINTELPRO promoted in US organizations in the 60s and 70s (when they weren’t outright murdering the party members).

    How’d that one work out?

    It’s easy to deflect workers off the path of real, lasting change when even the organizers only try to do sloganeering instead of education.



  • Roy Wood Jr. is hilarious and so is Hannibal Buress, pretty much anything from them is great.

    Stavros Halkias has good specials, just don’t go near the crowd work (but that’s pretty much every comic).

    Aamer Rahman is great and he just came out from hiatus, check his older stuff first and see if you like it.

    Michael Che has good stand up too, even if you know him from SNL and don’t like his stuff there.




  • Grapho@lemmy.mltoMemes@lemmy.mlConspiracies
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    6 days ago

    The US did lie about Nelson Mandela being a bloodthirsty terrorist who would immediately genocide all the white people, but not about Hamas. Why don’t you condemn terrorists?

    The state department did lie about Libya’s threat and was involved in the horrible dismantling of their state in favor of jihadi warlords, but not in Syria, why are you linking non credible journalists? No I will not check the leaked documents.

    The CIA WAS confirmed to have instigated hundreds of coups as recently as the 2010s, but not in Ukraine. You’d have to be a bot to believe such nonsense.

    The US did lie about Cuba being a brutal totalitarian baby murdering state, and did downplay how horribly exploitative and violent they were in their imperialism before the revolution, but you have to believe North Korean defectors, it’s not like they’re being bribed to say the biggest lie they can. Btw they had the Korean genuhhhhhh… War coming, they did invade the south of their own country and that’s the part the US wanted.


  • Grapho@lemmy.mltoMemes@lemmy.mlConspiracies
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    5 days ago

    And you see some of those people here acting like they’re immune to propaganda, that they care when they blatantly disregard sources when presented to them on controversial topics (read: against the US State department line). As principled as they think they are, you talk about anything outside the US or whatever US vassal state they’re from, and it’s back to the chauvinism, but with a pink coat of paint.

    I think Roderic Day had it right when he said this was an issue of westerners consenting to their own misinformation because they don’t want to face that they’re complicit by inaction in the horrible shit their governments have done to the third world for centuries and continue on a daily basis. And Zizek does that shit all the time too, arguing for western chauvinist shit but for “leftist” reasons, like he did in Against the Double Blackmail.